Systematic analysis of the measurement tools for nurses' career resilience

Abstract

Abstract: Objective To systematically analysis the domestic and international studies on evaluating the measurement tools of the nurses' career resilience,and provide evidences for developing a cultural adaptive scale on nurses' career resilience. Methods According to the methodological framework of systematic review,the Cochrane Library,PubMed,Embase,Web of Science,China Biomedical Literature Database,CNKI,Wanfang Database,and VIP Database were systematically searched from the establishment of the database till the publication date of April 7,2022,and selected relevant literature that met the inclusion criteria to evaluate the professional resilience of nurses. The study quality was evaluated using the relevant quality evaluation tool of the evidence-based health care center of Joanna Briggs Institute（JBI） in Australia,and trace the original research on the evaluation tools used in the literature,summarize and evaluate the characteristics of the evaluation tools. Results A total of 17 studies（12 in China and 5 in other countries） were included,of which 3 were measurement tool development studies on nurses' career resilience. The included studies involved 10 kinds of measurement tools,but only one of which was developed specifically for the nurses（one in China）,two（in other countries） of which were developed for medical personnel（including nurses）,and the others were universal career resilience scales. There were 11-32 items and 3-7 dimensions in the scale with much diversity. Conclusions There is a lack of professional resilience assessment tools targeting the specific characteristics of the nursing population. In the future,it is possible to develop nurse professional resilience assessment tools that are suitable for China's cultural characteristics,taking into account China's national conditions and medical background.

Key words: Nurses, Career resilience, Evaluation tools, Systematic analysis

CLC Number:

R181.2

XIAN Yajing, LI Yunfan, PENG Wenwen, YAN Ping, LIN Sulan, LI Xianhong. Systematic analysis of the measurement tools for nurses' career resilience. [J]OCCUPATION AND HEALTH, 2024, 40(7): 973-978.

References

[1] LONDON M.Toward a theory of career motivation[J].Acad Manage Rev, 1983,8(4):620-630.
[2] HART P L,BRANNAN J D,DE CHESNAY M.Resilience in nurses:An integrative review[J].J Nurs Manag,2014,22(6):720-734.
[3] MANOMENIDIS G,PANAGOPOULOU E,MONTGOMERY A.Resilience in nursing:The role of internal and external factors[J].J Nurs Manag,2019,27(1):172-178.
[4] BONAMER J R,AQUINO-RUSSELL C.Self-care strategies for professional development:Transcendental meditation reduces compassion fatigue and improves resilience for nurses[J].J Nurses Prof Dev,2019, 35(2):93-97.
[5] 周英凤,顾莺,胡雁,等.JBI循证卫生保健中心对关于不同类型研究的质量评价工具——患病率及分析性横断面研究的质量评价[J].护士进修杂志,2018,33(3):219-221.
[6] MORENO-JIMÉNEZ B,RODRÍGUEZ-MUÑOZ A,GARROSA HERN-ÁNDEZ E,et al.Development and validation of the occupational hardiness questionnaire[J].Psicothema,2014,26(2):207-214.
[7] 张婷,李惠萍,窦婉君,等.专科护士职业韧性及影响因素分析[J].中华行为医学与脑科学杂志,2015,24(2):158-161.
[8] 张阳春,林征,季学丽.综合性三级甲等医院急危重症护士职业韧性对职业生涯高原影响的研究[J].中国护理管理,2016,16(11):1520-1525.
[9] MALLAK L A,YILDIZ M.Developing a workplace resilience instrument[J].Work,2016,54(2):241-253.
[10] 陈琳,李霞,夏明辉.武汉市神经内科护士职业韧性与职业生涯高原反应的调查[J].职业与健康,2018,34(19):2662-2664.
[11] 吴秀玉,刘用玲.低年资护士职业韧性对职业生涯状况影响的相关性分析[J].当代医学,2018,24(12):111-113.
[12] TAU B,DU PLESSIS E,KOEN D,et al.The relationship between resilience andempowering leader behaviour of nurse managers in the mining healthcare sector[J].Curationis,2018,41(1):e1-e10.
[13] 王艳平,王万军,祖晓军.急诊科护士自我职业生涯管理及核心自我评价对职业弹性的影响[J].护理学杂志,2019,34(12):61-64.
[14] 魏永婷,代晓峰,王赫,等.手术室专科护士主动性人格、职业价值观对职业弹性的影响研究[J].中华现代护理杂志,2019,25(33):4349-4353.
[15] WALPITA Y N,ARAMBEPOLA C.High resilience leads to better work performance in nurses:Evidence from South Asia[J].J Nurs Manag,2020,28(2):342-350.
[16] 杜爱燕,周薇,李另另,等.无锡21所血液净化中心护士职业韧性与社会支持的相关性研究[J].江苏卫生事业管理,2021,32(5):583-587.
[17] 房欣. 护士职业韧性、职业认同与工作生活质量的相关性研究[D]长春:长春中医药大学,2021.
[18] 易丽玉,郭慧兰.急诊科护士职业韧性与主观幸福感的相关性研究[J].当代护士:上旬刊,2021,28(5):19-23.
[19] 朱雪梅,杨朝霞,于晓燕.护理人员职业生涯韧性现状及其影响因素分析[J].护士进修杂志,2021,36(21):1972-1975.
[20] 项凤鸣,张丹云,周洁,等.领悟社会支持在低年资护士情绪稳定性和职业弹性间的中介效应[J].护理与康复,2021,20(5):7-11.
[21] DELGADO C,ROCHE M,FETHNEY J,et al.Mental health nurses' psychological well-being,mental distress,and workplace resilience:A cross-sectional survey[J].Int J Ment Health Nurs,2021,30(5):1234-1247.
[22] 朱雪梅,泥敏,杨朝霞,等.护理人员职业生涯韧性问卷的编制及信效度检验[J].护士进修杂志,2021,36(11):973-976.
[23] WAGNILD G M Y H.Development and psychometric evaluation of the ResilienceScale[J].J Nurs Meas,1993,1(2):165-178.
[24] 李霞. 职业弹性的结构研究及测量工具开发[J].管理学报,2011, 8(11):1625-1629.
[25] 曾华. 职业弹性的影响因素及作用实证研究[D]广东:广东商学院,2011.
[26] GRZEDA M M,PRINCE J B.Career motivation measures:A testof convergent and discriminant validity[J].Int J Hum Resour Manag,1997, 8(2):172-196.
[27] 余肖楠,张建新.自我韧性量表与 Connor-Davidson 韧性量表的应用比较[J].心理科学,2007,30(5):1169-1171.
[28] 国肖娜. IT人员职业弹性与离职意愿关系的实证研究[D]大连:东北财经大学,2013.
[29] 宋国学. 职业生涯韧性的结构维度:本土化研究[J].经济管理,2011(11):184-193.
[30] WINWOOD P C,COLON R,MCEWEN K.A practical measure of workplace resilience[J].J Occup Environ Med,2013,55(10):1205-1212.
[31] 朱雪梅. 护理人员职业生涯韧性指标体系的构建及实证研究[D].济南:山东第一医科大学,2019.
[32] KUMPFER K L.Factors and processes contributing to resilience[M].//GLANTZ M D,JOHNSON J L.Resilience and development:Positive life adaptations.New York:Springer,2002:179-224.