Visual analysis of human papilloma virus vaccine health transmission in China and abroad based on CiteSpace

Abstract

Abstract: Objective To analyze the human papilloma virus（HPV） vaccine health transmission in China and abroad in the past decade,explore the research hotspots and development trends of HPV vaccine health transmission,and provide reference for future research. Methods Chinese and English articles related to HPV vaccine health communication included in China National Knowledge Infrastructure（CNKI） and Web of Science（WoS） core set databases from 2014 to 2023 were searched,and CiteSpace software was used to analyze keywords,authors and publishing institutions and draw knowledge maps. Results A total of 811 articles were included in the analysis,and the number of HPV vaccine health communication literature was generally on the rise. The most frequent keywords in Chinese and English articles were cognitive level（61 times） and Adolescent（171 times）,respectively,and these researches focus on HPV vaccine coverage,public awareness and attitudes towards HPV vaccine,and interventions based on digital technology. The provider recommendation behavior,vaccine hesitancy and misinformation were emerging persistent keywords until 2023. The cooperation between domestic and foreign research authors and institutions was relatively loose. Both domestic and international research fields were mainly focused on the field of oncology medicine. The main populations of foreign studies were adolescents,parents of adolescents,and females,while the main populations of domestic studies are college students. Conclusion The number of research articles on HPV vaccine health transmission in China and abroad has increased year by year,which has attracted the attention of domestic and foreign scholars. The research frontiers are the improvement of provider recommendation behavior,the elimination of vaccine hesitation,and the public's recognition of misinformation. Although domestic and international studies show some differences in the objects and methods of health transmission,it is still a common concern that how to improve the public's cognition and attitude toward HPV vaccine based on digital technology intervention strategies,and to improve the vaccine coverage rate subsequently.

Key words: Human papilloma virus, Health Transmission, CiteSpace, Visualization, Analyze

CLC Number:

R181.2

DU Miao, ZHOU Yuan, HAN Longzhe, JIN Lihua. Visual analysis of human papilloma virus vaccine health transmission in China and abroad based on CiteSpace. [J]OCCUPATION AND HEALTH, 2025, 41(18): 2557-2563.

References

[1] 高飞,张姝玥,王致萍,等.人乳头瘤病毒疫苗的研究现状及前景[J]. 中国生物制品学杂志,2022,35(7):769-79.
[2] ZOU K N,HUANG Y,LI Z Y.Prevention and treatment of human papillomavirus in men benefits both men and women[J].Front Cell Infect Microbiol,2022,12:1077651.
[3] ZHU B,YU H,NI P,et al.A population-based cross-sectional study on the situation of cervical cancer screening in Liaoning,China[J]. Bmc Womens Health,2023,23(1):144.
[4] 宋祎凡,刘晓雪,尹遵栋,等. 2018—2020年中国9~45岁女性人乳头瘤病毒疫苗估算接种率[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2021,27(5):570-575.
[5] WHO.Human papillomavirus vaccines:WHO position paper,May 2017-Recommendations[J].Vaccine,2017,35(43):5753-5755.
[6] ROGERS E M.The field of health communication today:An up-to-date report[J].J Health Commun,1996,1(1):15-23.
[7] 张师前,王凯,张远丽.HPV疫苗在中国的应用现状[J].中国实用妇科与产科杂志,2019,35(10):1090-1095.
[8] 陈悦,陈超美,刘则渊,等.CiteSpace知识图谱的方法论功能[J].科学学研究,2015,33(2):242-253.
[9] 史春杨,叶协杰.《中国科技期刊研究》2003—2005年载文、作者及引文分析[J].中国科技期刊研究,2007,18(1):65-68.
[10] SERRANO B,ALEMANY L,TOUS S,et al.Potential impact of a nine-valent vaccine in human papillomavirus related cervical disease[J].Infect Agents Cancer,2012,7:1-13.
[11] 郭冬丽. 宫颈癌二价疫苗与四价疫苗有效性及安全性系统评价[D].太原:山西医科大学,2018.
[12] LEI J,PLONER A,ELFSTRÖM K M,et al.HPV vaccination and the risk of invasive cervical cancer[J].N Engl J Med,2020,383(14):1340-1348.
[13] World Health Organization.World Health Assembly adopts global strategy to accelerate cervical cancer elimination[EB/OL].(2020-08-19)[2024-11-26].https://www.who.int/news-room/detail/19-08-2020-world-health-assembly-adopts-global-strategy-toaccelerate-cervical-cancer-elimination.
[14] World Health Organization.One-dose human papillomavirus(HPV) vaccine offers solid protection against cervical cancer[EB/OL].(2022-04-11)[2024-11-26].https://www.who.int/news/item/11-04-2022-one-dose-human-papillomavirus-(hpv)-vaccine-offers-solid-protection-againstce-rvical-cancer.
[15] 张习习,史金晶,张肇南,等.中小学女生及其母亲人乳头瘤病毒疫苗接种现况和家长对疫苗接种的健康信念调查[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2022,28(2):184-188,198.
[16] 陈伟,李彦坤,吴小丽,等.2018—2021年天津市适龄女性人乳头瘤病毒疫苗接种率分析[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2022,28(6):684-689.
[17] BRUNI L,SAURA-LAZARO A,MONTOLIU A,et al.HPV vaccination introduction worldwide and WHO and UNICEF estimates of national HPV immunization coverage 2010-2019[J].Prev Med,2021,144:106399.
[18] DA COSTA NUNES J F,PIRES S,CHADE D C.Human papillomavirus vaccination and prevention of intraepithelial neoplasia and penile cancer:review article[J].Curr Opin Urol,2020,30(2):208-212.
[19] HARDER T,WICHMANN O,KLUG S J,et al.Efficacy,effectiveness and safety of vaccination against human papillomavirus in males:A systematic review[J].BMC Med,2018,16:1-14.
[20] 滕秋丽,牛茂源,刘玉莹,等.HPV感染对男性的危害与HPV疫苗接种对男性的保护[J].中国免疫学杂志,2022,38(4):507-514.
[21] LOKE A Y,KWAN M L,WONG Y T,et al.The uptake of human papillomavirus vaccination and its associated factors among adolescents:A systematic review[J].J PrimCare Communit,2017,8(4):349-362.
[22] ASGEDOM Y S,KEBEDE T M,SEIFU B L,et al.Human papillomavirus vaccination uptake and determinant factors among adolescent schoolgirls in sub-saharan africa:A systematic review and meta-analysis[J].Hum Vacc Immunother,2024,20(1):2326295.
[23] 郭红,张圣悦,张洁洁,等.中国首个人乳头瘤病毒疫苗免费接种城市疫苗接种进展研究[J].中国慢性病预防与控制,2024,32(3):198-201,207.
[24] 于洋,李瑞英,李美兰,等.HPV疫苗上市后中国女学生HPV疫苗知识和接受性的变化[J].中国健康教育,2021,37(5):434-439,443.
[25] 张佳莹,韩颖,王瑞杰,等.不同人群对人乳头瘤病毒及HPV疫苗的知信行调查研究[J].中国健康教育,2020,36(2):147-152.
[26] MANSFIELD L N,ONSOMU E O,MERWIN E,et al.Association between parental hpv knowledge and intentions to have their daughters vaccinated[J].Western J Nurs Res,2018,40(4):481-501.
[27] TAN S,WANG S,ZOU X,et al.Parental willingness of HPV vaccination in Mainland China:A meta-analysis[J].Hum Vaccines Immunother,2024,20(1):2314381.
[28] 郭冠群,吴昊.国内祖辈参与养育研究现状及问题分析[J].湖州师范学院学报,2023,45(5):47-54.
[29] World Health Organization.Ten threats to global health in 2019[EB/OL].(2019-01-14)[2024-11-26].https://www.who.int/emergencies/ten-threats-toglobal-health-in-2019
[30] CHEN X,WANG L,HUANG Y,et al.Risk perception and trust in the relationship between knowledge and HPV vaccine hesitancy among female university students in China:A cross-sectional study[J].Bmc Public Health,2024,24(1):667-674.
[31] CHATTERJEE A,O'KEEFE C.Current controversies in the USA regarding vaccine safety[J].Expert RevVaccines,2010,9(5):497-502.
[32] 郑文新,叶瑜,许伟杰,等.农村女性人乳头瘤病毒疫苗接种情况研究综述[J].中国农村卫生,2022,14(11):70-72.
[33] 冯旸子,刘朝晖.HPV疫苗对女性生育力影响的研究现状[J].中国妇产科临床杂志,2024,25(2):190-192.
[34] WANG H,WANG X Y,CHEN P P,et al.Effect of health intervention via web-based education on improving information-motivation-behavioral skills related to hpv vaccination among chinese female college students[J].Int J Public Health,2023,68:1605596.
[35] ZHANG X,CHEN H,ZHOU J,et al.Impact of web-based health education on HPV vaccination uptake among college girl students in Western and Northern China:A follow-up study[J].Bmc Womens Health,2022,22(1):46.
[36] FEEMSTER K A,HEAD K J,PANOZZO C A,et al.Efficacy of tailored messages to improve behavioral intent to accept HPV vaccination among mothers may be moderated by sociodemographics[J].Prev Med Rep,2021,23:101413.
[37] KIM K,PAREKH DE CAMPOS A,CHOI S.A vax4hpv mobile application for parents of human papillomavirus vaccine-eligible children:Iterative formative assessments[J].Comput Inform Nurs,2022,40(7):455-465.
[38] BULLER D B,PAGOTO S,HENRY K,et al.Human papillomavirus vaccination and social media:Results in a trial with mothers of daughters aged 14-17[J].Front Digit Health,2021,3:683034.
[39] RUIZ-LOPEZ T,SEN S,JAKOBSEN E,et al.Fight HPV:Design and evaluation of a mobile game to raise awareness about human papillomavirus and nudge people to take action against cervical cancer[J].Jmir Serious Games,2019,7(2):e8540.
[40] 李小雪,李漫漫,张俊,等.中国女大学生HPV疫苗健康教育效果的系统评价[J].全科护理,2022,20(27):3750-3753.
[41] DEMPSEY A F,MAERTENS J,SEVICK C,et al.A randomized,controlled,pragmatic trial of an iPad-based,tailored messaging intervention to increase human papillomavirus vaccination among Latinos[J].Hum Vacc Immunother,2019,15(7-8):1577-1584.
[42] MOHAMMADZADEH N,SAFDARI R,RAHIMI A.Cancer care management through a mobile phone health approach:Key considerations[J].Asian Pac J Cancer P,2013,14(9):4961-4964.
[43] 徐倩,田烨.健康传播视域下自媒体HPV疫苗报道现状及策略研究——以“丁香医生”微信公众号为例[J].新闻世界,2024(2):60-63.
[44] LIN Y,SU Z,CHEN F,et al.Chinese mothers' intention to vaccinate daughters against human papillomavirus(HPV),and their vaccine preferences:a study in Fujian Province[J].Hum Vacc Immunother,2021,17(1):304-315.
[45] LAMA Y,QIN Y,NAN X,et al.Human papillomavirus vaccine acceptability and campaign message preferences among african american parents:A qualitative study[J].J Cancer Educ,2022,37(6):1691-1701.
[46] XU M A,CHOI J,CAPASSO A,et al.Patient-provider health communication strategies:Enhancing HPV vaccine uptake among adolescents of color[J].Healthcare,2023,11(12):1702.