Advances in research on workplace incivility suffered by clinical nurses

Abstract

Abstract: ：The workplace incivility（WI）,although it is a kind of interpersonal deviation behavior with vague intention of harm and relatively mild degree,violates the basic norms of mutual respect in the workplace,and has a high incidence rate. It can evolve into workplace bullying and workplace violence,which seriously threatens the physical and mental health and occupational health of nurses. WI can lead to anxiety,burnout,reduced job satisfaction,decreased performance,increased turnover intention and a series of adverse outcomes.Therefore,it is important to pay attention to and explore WI in the nursing field for the stable development of nursing team. The paper expounds the concept and characteristics of WI,assessment tools,status quo and adverse outcomes of clinical nurses suffering from WI,aiming to provide reference for nursing managers to seek effective intervention measures for WI.

Key words: Workplace incivility, Clinical nurses, Advances in research

CLC Number:

R181.3

ZHANG Jun-fu, ZHANG Yu-fang, MENG Wen-qi, YANG Yue-bo. Advances in research on workplace incivility suffered by clinical nurses. [J]OCCUPATION AND HEALTH, 2023, 39(10): 1426-1440.

References

[1] KAISER J A.The relationship between leadership style and nurse-to-nurse incivility:Turning the lens inward[J].J Nurs Manag,2017,25(2):110-118.
[2] PATEL S E,CHRISMAN M.Incivility through the continuum of nursing:A concept analysis[J].Nurs Forum,2020,55(2):267-274.
[3] LAYNE D M,ANDERSON E,HENDERSON S.Examining the presence and sources of incivility within nursing[J].J Nurs Manag,2019,27(7):1505-1511.
[4] HUTTON S,GATES D.Workplace incivility and productivity losses among direct care staff[J].AAOHN J,2008,56(4):168-175.
[5] PHILLIPS G S,MACKUSICK C I,WHICHELLO R.Workplace incivility in nursing:A literature review through the lens of ethics and spirituality[J].J Christ Nurs,2018,35(1):E7-E12.
[6] HUNT C,MARINI Z A.Incivility in the practice environment:A perspective from clinical nursing teachers[J].Nurse Educ Pract,2012,12(6):366-370.
[7] ARMSTRONG N.Management of nursing workplace incivility in the health care settings:A systematic review[J].Workplace Health Saf,2018,66(8):403-410.
[8] ANDERSSON L M,PEARSON C M.Tit for tat? The spiraling effect of incivility in the workplace[J].Acad Manage Rev,1999,24(3):452-471.
[9] BLACKSTOCK S,CUMMINGS G,GLANFIELD F,et al.A review:Developing an ecological model approach to co-worker incivility experiences of new graduate nurses[J].J Adv Nurs,2022,78(6):1535-1550.
[10] GHOSH R.Workplace incivility in Asia-how do we take a socio-cultural perspective?[J].Human Resource Development International,2017,20(4):263-267.
[11] CORTINA L M,MAGLEY V J,WILLIAMS J H,et al.Incivility in the workplace:Incidence and impact[J].J Occup Health Psychol,2001,6(1):64-80.
[12] CORTINA L M,KABAT-FARR D,LESKINEN E A,et al.Selective Incivility as Modern Discrimination in Organizations Evidence and Impact[J].J Manage,2013,39(6):1579-1605.
[13] 孟德昕,时宇,谢奉哲,等.新入职护士经历工作场所无礼行为测量及对离职意愿影响[J].中国医院管理,2017,37(5):62-64.
[14] GUIDROZ A M,BURNFIELD-GEIMER J L,CLARK O,et al.The nursing incivility scale:Development and validation of an occupation-specific measure[J].J Nurs Meas,2010,18(3):176-200.
[15] ANTHONY M,YASTIK J,MACDONALD D A,et al.Development and validation of a tool to measure incivility in clinical nursing education[J].J Prof Nurs,2014,30(1):48-55.
[16] 崔沙沙,张蕾,孔德华,等.中文版临床护理教育不文明行为量表信效度研究[J].解放军护理杂志,2017,34(18):21-25.
[17] 徐佳,韩永红,钟文娟.情绪智力在临床护理教育不文明行为与护生学习倦怠间的中介作用[J].全科护理,2022,20(7):876-880.
[18] MARTIN R J,HINE D W.Development and validation of the uncivil workplace behavior questionnaire[J].J Occup Health Psychol,2005,10(4):477-490.
[19] 刘嫦娥,戴万稳.中国情境下工作场所无礼行为的结构探讨[J].管理学报,2011,8(12):1818-1822.
[20] LEWIS P S,MALECHA A.The impact of workplace incivility on the work environment,manager skill,and productivity[J].J Nurs Adm,2011,41(1):41-47.
[21] LASCHINGER H K S,CUMMINGS G,LEITER M,et al.Starting out:A time-lagged study of new graduate nurses’transition to practice[J].Int J Nurs Stud,2016,57:82-95.
[22] ALSHEHRY A S,ALQUWEZ N,ALMAZAN J,et al.Workplace incivility and its influence on professional quality of life among nurses from multicultural background:A cross-sectional study[J].J Clin Nurs,2019,28(13-14):2553-2564.
[23] LEE Y H,LEE J,LEE S K.The mediating effect of workplace incivility on organization culture in South Korea:A descriptive correlational analysis of the turnover intention of nurses[J].J Nurs Scholarsh,2022,54(3):367-375.
[24] SMITH L M,ANDRUSYSZYN M A,SPENCE LASCHINGER H K.Effects of workplace incivility and empowerment on newly-graduated nurses’organizational commitment[J].J Nurs Manag,2010,18(8):1004-1015.
[25] ZHANG S,MA C,MENG D,et al.Impact of workplace incivility in hospitals on the work ability,career expectations and job performance of Chinese nurses:A cross-sectional survey[J].BMJ Open,2018,8(12):e021874.
[26] 曹丽,郭伟.护士工作场所不文明行为、工作满意度及其对离职意愿的影响[J].中西医结合护理(中英文),2019,5(2):152-154.
[27] KANITHA D,NAIK P R.Experience of workplace incivility and its impact on stress and turnover intention among the nurses working at a hospital:Cross-sectional survey approach[J].Iran J Nurs Midwifery Res,2021,26(3):285.
[28] ABDOLLAHZADEH F,ASGHARI E,EBRAHIMI H,et al.How to prevent workplace incivility?:Nurses' perspective[J].Iran J Nurs Midwifery Res,2017,22(2):157.
[29] RAMSEY-HAYNES S.Emotional intelligence and workplace incivility among oncology RNs[J].Nurs Manage,2021,52(10):10-14.
[30] SMITH J G,MORIN K H,LAKE E T.Association of the nurse work environment with nurse incivility in hospitals[J].J Nurs Manag,2018,26(2):219-226.
[31] MIKAELIAN B,STANLEY D.Incivility in nursing:from roots to repair[J].J Nurs Manag,2016,24(7):962-969.
[32] ZHANG D,SONG H,LIU Y,et al.The influence of workplace incivility on the fatigue of female nurses:The mediating effect of engagement[J].J Nurs Manag,2022,30(6):1514-1522.
[33] SHI Y,GUO H,ZHANG S,et al.Impact of workplace incivility against new nurses on job burn-out:A cross-sectional study in China[J].BMJ Open,2018,8(4):e020461.
[34] KHAN M S,ELAHI N S,ABID G.Workplace incivility and job satisfaction:Mediation of subjective well-being and moderation of forgiveness climate in health care sector[J].Eur J Investig Health Psychol Educ,2021,11(4):1107-1119.
[35] 刘嫦娥,黄杰,谢玮,等.上级无礼行为对员工工作投入的影响机制研究[J].管理学报,2019,16(9):1344-1352.
[36] 王晓玉,李金萍,梁超.情感承诺在新护士无礼行为感知与工作投入间的中介效应[J].护理学报,2021,28(21):57-61.
[37] ALSHEHRY A S,ALQUWEZ N,ALMAZAN J,et al.Influence of workplace incivility on the quality of nursing care[J].J Clin Nurs,2019,28(23-24):4582-4594.
[38] ALQUWEZ N.Examining the influence of workplace incivility on nurses' patient safety competence[J].J Nurs Scholarsh,2020,52(3):292-300.
[39] ALQUWEZ N.Association between nurses’experiences of workplace incivility and the culture of safety of hospitals:A cross-sectional Study[J].J Clin Nurs,2022,16230.
[40] KERBER C,WOITH W M,JENKINS S H,et al.Perceptions of new nurses concerning incivility in the workplace[J].J Contin Educ Nurs,2015,46(11):522-527.
[41] 唐瑶,黄惠根.护士安全感的研究进展[J].护理研究,2022,36(7):1194-1197.
[42] HOWARD M S,EMBREE J L.Educational intervention improves communication abilities of nurses encountering workplace incivility[J].J Contin Educ Nurs,2020,51(3):138-144.
[43] MCDERMOTT C,BERNARD N,HATHAWAY W.Taking a stand against workplace incivility[J].J Contin Educ Nurs,2021,52(5):232-239.
[44] CARMONA-COBO I,LOPEZ-ZAFRA E.Hospital nurses experiencing day-to-day workplace incivility:A diary study on the benefits of daily social support[J].J Nurs Manag,2022,30(6):1577-1589.
[45] 陈林,章一华.医务人员工作场所暴力研究进展[J].中国职业医学,2020,47(4):495-497,500.